Given that my last post discourages entrepreneurs from raising debt apart from a few specific cases namely:
1. Very high ROCE low risk businesses  (P.s. Tell me if you are in one of these)
2. Quick Flip businesses where you are adding value to an asset,
Let us go to what then an entrepreneur needs to do to get his business adequate capital. If not debt, then the corollary is essentially Equity capital. Equity capital is where an investor invests capital and in return takes ownership of a chunk of the business  e.g. 1mn USD for 30%. Now debt is a simple proposition  most entrepreneurs understand that if they were to borrow from a private individual the rate of interest would probably be higher as compared to the rate of interest were they to borrow from a financial institution and likewise an investor would also intuitively guess that if a bank were to give him x % per annum for his money, he should get x+++% for his money were he to lend to a business. However, this intuitiveness usually breaks down when it comes to discussing an equity investment. Both investors and entrepreneurs seem to not have a clear sense of how equity should be valued.
So here are some of my thoughts on the same:
Firstly, I feel eventually all businesses tend to be valued based on the DCF method. Of all the methods that I have found this is effectively the method I feel is logical, scientific and pretty much accounts for most things I feel should be accounted for.
For the sake of my analysis, let us assume that you were in a zero risk business that would with clockwork precision every year keep paying you 100$ on the anniversary of that year. It would pay you this forever  How much would you sell this business to me for? To answer this question, you would need to know the prevailing bank interest rate  because effectively the only other investment that would be comparable would be a term deposit. So if the bank interest rate was 10%  you could tell me that this is a great alternative to putting 1000$ in a term deposit. If the bank interest rate was 1%, you could justify selling it to me for 10,000$ as a replacement for a 10,000$ term deposit. However, there is no way that I would pay 1010$ if the bank interest rate was 10% or 10,010$ if the bank interest rate was 1% if I was a logical thinking person.
To keep it simple, let me now touch on the reason behind the discount in the DCF. Essentially money today is worth more than the same money if given to me in the future as if I had that money today, I could put it to work  at the worst case by putting it in a bank and in the best case by putting it into other speculative investments. As such, I would discount next years earnings by a %age  minimum the return I would get from a bank  and I would discount 2 years forward earnings by the same %age compounded twice and so on so forth.
To complete this simplistic analysis of DCF we have to factor in that businesses grow or decline  so for instance if a business was growing  the earnings shareholders would benefit from would grow and if it was declining the earnings available to shareholders may decline or else they might have to put in further capital if it were to incur losses. Either ways, we have to factor in the growth or decline in future cash flows.
Lastly, businesses are always uncertain and are affected my many external factors  as such both entrepreneurs and investors have to look at the probability of the business reaching a particular scale and then maintaining that scale for a significant amount of time.
Now coming to valuation  to figure out valuation let's take a live example 
A young company requires 1mn USD. It's cash flows are projected to look like below:
Y1  500,000$
Y2  300,000$
Y3  200,000$
Y4  50,000$
Y5  100,000$
Y6  200,000$
Y7  500,000$
Y8  500,000$
Y9 500,000$ and so on so forth.
On the face of it, this is a great business  the company has consumed only 1,000,000$ in capital and is throwing out 500,000$ in cash per year. However, let's look at it from the view point of the investor who is being asked to invest 1,000,000$
Step 1: What is the prevailing interest rate? If the interest rate is 10%  the maximum that he could value the business throwing out 500,000$ in cash in perpetuity is $5,000,000.
As such, the first call the investor should make is how long he expects this 500,000$ to last  so let's say if he had a crystal ball  and could look sitting in year 0 as far beyond as Y 15  he could say that the company would generate 500,000$ for 6 more years so till Y15.
Now he would have to calculate the present value of these cash flows discounted by at least the interest rate  10%. This would look like this
Giving a value of $1.8mn for these cash flows.
Put in another way  for investing 1mn $  the investor should own 1/1.8 or at least 55% of the business. This is only if he is 100% certain that the business will generate such cash flows as per the projections. In life nothing is certain and so it's wise to discount by 25%  and so the investor would reach a valuation of 1.35mn USD or to put it differently  his stake for investing 1mn USD should be a minimum of 75%.
Remember that we have here discounted by 25% for all risks such as:
1. The product not having a market.
2. Competitive forces outgunning the business.
3. Economics of the business degrading.
4. Management and litigation risk.
5. The business raising further capital diluting the investor and thus diluting his share of future cash flows.
6. Team friction and other reasons why the business could implode.
As such, in general it is apt to discount by 75%.
Given all of the above, it is the responsibility of the entrepreneur to first introspect if his business firstly has the potential to generate the sort of cash flows that account for a brutal valuation exercise as given above. If he feels so, it is his responsibility to then construct a deal that leaves enough on the table for the investors. How can he do this?
Rule 0: Do detailed math and raise with some margin of safety. All projections go haywire if your investors get diluted in a distress situation.
Rule 1: Be Frugal and capital efficient. This will ensure that the profits are significant in comparison to capital invested.
Rule 2: Focus on speed. Remember the discount is compounded by the number of years. Time will kill investor returns if you are not mindful.
So having said this what do you value a business at  I like to think of the following as a typical example of cash flows:
Y1 400,000$
Y2  400,000$
Y3  200,000$
Y4  200,000$
Y5  100,000$
Y6  500,000$
Y7  1000000$
Y8  1000000$
Y9  1500000$
Y10  1500000$
A business like this I would typically take the positive value of 10 years of cash flow  so in this instance Y510 (6 years)  and calculate the NPV of the same  and assign that as the valuation of the business  In this case it would be 2.5mn USD  If I felt the business was highly probable to not meet the projections  it would be a no go. As such my advice to an entrepreneur who arrived with the above projections  1. Do more with less capital. Try to burn less money in the initial days. 2. Try to innovate so that Y10 cash flows remain steady and growing for maybe another 15 years  giving both him and me more upside given that we both would make very limited money in the present construct.
I hope this has been useful.
A collection of my writings on life, business, the world at large. My attempts to share what I have learned through the mistakes made and interactions with wiser friends.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
If not debt, then equity?
Given that my last post discourages entrepreneurs from raising debt apart from a few specific cases namely: 1. Very high ROCE low risk bus...

The sales function in any organization is often shrouded in awe, mystery and frequently derision. If you were to take a snap poll of startu...

One of the best parts of my stay in India was biking with my university friends in an around Bombay . We had a lot of fun biking to cities...

Image by hober via Flickr So everyone knows I have for a very long time been a product creator and innovator in the Telecom and Payments s...
No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for your comment. It should appear shortly.